Journalist Bites Leakers

There is stark debate between Jeff Toobin, the CNN legal analyst, and Glenn Greenwald, blogger and Guardian columnist over Bradley Manning’s transfer of State Dept. cables to Wikileaks. What makes Cablegate different from other leak cases is that the ship of state did not leak from the top, but from the bottom. It doesn’t get much lower than a private first class.

As Greenwald points out quite rightly, Manning leaked cables marked “Secret” or less (the classification goes confidential > secret > top secret). He did not disclose “Top Secret” documents and certainly not “Secure Compartmentalized Information,” secrets so secret that only specific persons are given access regardless of their clearance level. By contrast, Bob Woodward and scores of other Washington journalists frequently disclose such information when it is leaked to them (though in many, but not all cases, the underlying documents are not available to the public).

What makes the Manning case different from these leaks is that we have most of the documents available. This is similar to the Pentagon Papers, which the NY Times and then the Washington Post published. Like Manning, Daniel Ellsberg did not give the  newspapers the most sensitive documents, the four volumes of diplomatic records. Unlike the Manning case, Ellsberg had been a senior civilian officer in the Defense Dept.

Toobin’s position seems to be that when senior officials leak to establishment journalists, it is OK. But when junior officials leak to upstart journalists, it is a bad thing. Greenwald calls him on this. What Toobin omits in his quasi-defense of leaking is that even senior officials have no authority to leak documents. They cannot foretell what damage their actions might cause when they leak more highly classified knowledge. Particularly sensitive is the National Security Agency’s capacities to monitor electronic communications. Although there is nothing particularly secret about how the NSA is doing what it has done, an inadvertent disclosure of what else the NSA can or cannot do regardless of legal authority could be incredibly damaging to US intelligence efforts in other areas.

Greenwald makes a crucial point: the damage from Cablegate is quite possibly nil. No one has tied any cable that was leaked to any harm. Government officials have backed off assertions that serious damage would occur. Of course, the counterpoint is that the fortunate outcome in this case does not mean that widespread leaking would be more benign in other cases.

The broader issue is how document should be classified. As Greenwald notes — as have many government officials — the classification process is frequently abused to hide the truth and that many documents are classified with no solid grounds for secrecy. Despite repeated calls to reform the classification rules, the process remains convoluted.

Toobin’s support for the Manning verdict is bizarre. Legally, it may be the correct verdict, but Toobin’s derision of Manning is odd for a practicing journalist.  Toobin seems to have forgotten his roots. His first book was a memoir of his work for the Iran-Contra special prosecutor Lawrence Walsh, a job he took shortly out of law school. Toobin had to submit his manuscript to Walsh for review under his terms of employment, and a legal battle broke out when Walsh refused to approve it. Toobin took criticism for seemingly taking the low-level job in order to publish a tell-all book. To now turn and denounce a low-level leaker is the height of chutzpah.

 

891 thoughts on “Journalist Bites Leakers

  1. Pingback: payday loan
  2. Pingback: his explanation
  3. Pingback: Sound Hire Surrey
  4. Pingback: leslie
  5. Pingback: brett
  6. Pingback: lawrence
  7. Pingback: Tour
  8. Pingback: Marc
  9. Pingback: Matthew
  10. Pingback: Isaac
  11. Pingback: Harry
  12. Pingback: kenneth
  13. Pingback: robert
  14. Pingback: ronnie
  15. Pingback: Adrian
  16. Pingback: lee
  17. Pingback: Ian
  18. Pingback: carl
  19. Pingback: mathew
  20. Pingback: Jon
  21. Pingback: angel
  22. Pingback: Shannon
  23. Pingback: Lawrence
  24. Pingback: orlando
  25. Pingback: Christopher
  26. Pingback: andrew
  27. Pingback: Ted
  28. Pingback: payday loans
  29. Pingback: Jon
  30. Pingback: Micheal
  31. Pingback: herbert
  32. Pingback: hugh
  33. Pingback: Robert
  34. Pingback: Frank
  35. Pingback: Gerard
  36. Pingback: Scott
  37. Pingback: Perry
  38. Pingback: Carlos
  39. Pingback: Darryl
  40. Pingback: Clifton
  41. Pingback: Nick
  42. Pingback: Marion
  43. Pingback: dan
  44. Pingback: Seth
  45. Pingback: warren
  46. Pingback: karl
  47. Pingback: george
  48. Pingback: Joshua
  49. Pingback: wallace
  50. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  51. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  52. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  53. Pingback: loja diesel
  54. Pingback: doutor rolex
  55. Pingback: doutor rolex
  56. Pingback: relógio rolex
  57. Pingback: doutor rolex
  58. Pingback: rolex preço
  59. Pingback: rolex brasil
  60. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  61. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  62. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  63. Pingback: relógios diesel
  64. Pingback: rolex brasil
  65. Pingback: relógio armani
  66. Pingback: relógios rolex
  67. Pingback: comprar rolex
  68. Pingback: relógio rolex
  69. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  70. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  71. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  72. Pingback: armani ar5860
  73. Pingback: rolex feminino
  74. Pingback: doutor rolex
  75. Pingback: relógio armani
  76. Pingback: relógio rolex
  77. Pingback: comprar rolex
  78. Pingback: relógio armani
  79. Pingback: armani ar5860
  80. Pingback: relógio diesel
  81. Pingback: diesel brasil
  82. Pingback: loja diesel
  83. Pingback: relógios diesel
  84. Pingback: diesel brasil
  85. Pingback: comprar rolex
  86. Pingback: rolex feminino
  87. Pingback: armani ar5860
  88. Pingback: diesel brasil
  89. Pingback: relogios da armani
  90. Pingback: lojas armani
  91. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  92. Pingback: armani ar5860
  93. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  94. Pingback: loja diesel
  95. Pingback: relógios diesel
  96. Pingback: diesel brasil
  97. Pingback: comprar rolex
  98. Pingback: loja armani
  99. Pingback: rolex feminino
  100. Pingback: comprar rolex
  101. Pingback: armani ar5860
  102. Pingback: rolex preço
  103. Pingback: rolex preço
  104. Pingback: rolex original
  105. Pingback: relógio armani
  106. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  107. Pingback: relógio armani
  108. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  109. Pingback: diesel brasil
  110. Pingback: rolex feminino
  111. Pingback: rolex original
  112. Pingback: loja armani
  113. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  114. Pingback: rolex original
  115. Pingback: doutor rolex
  116. Pingback: armani ar5860
  117. Pingback: relógio armani
  118. Pingback: loja armani
  119. Pingback: lojas armani
  120. Pingback: relogios da armani
  121. Pingback: doutor rolex
  122. Pingback: rolex original
  123. Pingback: diesel brasil
  124. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  125. Pingback: rolex brasil
  126. Pingback: relógios rolex
  127. Pingback: loja armani
  128. Pingback: relógio armani
  129. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  130. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  131. Pingback: relógio rolex
  132. Pingback: don
  133. Pingback: rolex brasil
  134. Pingback: rolex brasil
  135. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  136. Pingback: relógios rolex
  137. Pingback: rolex original
  138. Pingback: rolex original
  139. Pingback: rolex feminino
  140. Pingback: diesel brasil
  141. Pingback: relógio diesel
  142. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  143. Pingback: rolex feminino
  144. Pingback: relógio rolex
  145. Pingback: loja armani
  146. Pingback: relógios diesel
  147. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  148. Pingback: relógio rolex
  149. Pingback: relógio armani
  150. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  151. Pingback: loja diesel
  152. Pingback: rolex feminino
  153. Pingback: rolex original
  154. Pingback: relógios rolex
  155. Pingback: loja diesel
  156. Pingback: rolex original
  157. Pingback: rolex original
  158. Pingback: relógio armani
  159. Pingback: comprar rolex
  160. Pingback: relógios rolex
  161. Pingback: diesel brasil
  162. Pingback: relógios diesel
  163. Pingback: relógio armani
  164. Pingback: relógio rolex
  165. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  166. Pingback: relógio rolex
  167. Pingback: doutor rolex
  168. Pingback: armani ar5860
  169. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  170. Pingback: gucci 太陽眼鏡
  171. Pingback: gucci 鑰匙包
  172. Pingback: gucci 皮夾
  173. Pingback: gucci 台灣
  174. Pingback: rolex preço
  175. Pingback: cinto gucci
  176. Pingback: novo mizuno
  177. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  178. Pingback: mizuno wave
  179. Pingback: mizuno wave
  180. Pingback: vans half cab
  181. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  182. Pingback: vans todo preto
  183. Pingback: vans era
  184. Pingback: comprar vans
  185. Pingback: air max feminino
  186. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  187. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  188. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  189. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  190. Pingback: tênis nike free
  191. Pingback: nike max air
  192. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  193. Pingback: vans era
  194. Pingback: air max azul
  195. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  196. Pingback: vans rosa
  197. Pingback: air max vermelho
  198. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  199. Pingback: vans masculino
  200. Pingback: tênis air max
  201. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  202. Pingback: tenis vans
  203. Pingback: tenis vans
  204. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  205. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  206. Pingback: vans half cab
  207. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  208. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  209. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  210. Pingback: vans half cab
  211. Pingback: tênis vans
  212. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  213. Pingback: tênis vans
  214. Pingback: novo mizuno
  215. Pingback: loja vans
  216. Pingback: mizuno wave
  217. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  218. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  219. Pingback: air max azul
  220. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  221. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  222. Pingback: vans todo preto
  223. Pingback: tênis air max
  224. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  225. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  226. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  227. Pingback: mizuno wave
  228. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  229. Pingback: vans era
  230. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  231. Pingback: nike free feminino
  232. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  233. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  234. Pingback: comprar vans
  235. Pingback: mizuno wave
  236. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  237. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  238. Pingback: nike air max preto
  239. Pingback: novo mizuno
  240. Pingback: comprar vans
  241. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  242. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  243. Pingback: vans old skool
  244. Pingback: novo mizuno
  245. Pingback: nike free feminino
  246. Pingback: tênis vans
  247. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  248. Pingback: tênis nike free
  249. Pingback: nike max air
  250. Pingback: vans half cab
  251. Pingback: vans old skool
  252. Pingback: vans era
  253. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  254. Pingback: air max vermelho
  255. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  256. Pingback: comprar vans
  257. Pingback: vans brasil
  258. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  259. Pingback: vans rosa
  260. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  261. Pingback: vans rosa
  262. Pingback: vans brasil
  263. Pingback: nike free feminino
  264. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  265. Pingback: air max vermelho
  266. Pingback: vans feminino
  267. Pingback: loja vans
  268. Pingback: lv 鑰匙包
  269. Pingback: lv 包包最新款
  270. Pingback: lv 皮夾
  271. Pingback: coach 包包
  272. Pingback: lv 旗艦店
  273. Pingback: gucci 手錶
  274. Pingback: gucci 台灣
  275. Pingback: lv 旗艦店
  276. Pingback: a&f 尺寸
  277. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  278. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  279. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  280. Pingback: a&f 官網
  281. Pingback: a&f outlet
  282. Pingback: a&f 台灣
  283. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  284. Pingback: a&f 代購
  285. Pingback: a&f 外套
  286. Pingback: a&f 香水
  287. Pingback: a&f 代購
  288. Pingback: rolex brasil
  289. Pingback: comprar vans
  290. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  291. Pingback: nike max air
  292. Pingback: tênis air max
  293. Pingback: novo air max
  294. Pingback: vans brasil
  295. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  296. Pingback: novo mizuno
  297. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  298. Pingback: novo air max
  299. Pingback: vans rosa
  300. Pingback: vans half cab
  301. Pingback: tênis nike free
  302. Pingback: vans old skool
  303. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  304. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  305. Pingback: air max feminino
  306. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  307. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  308. Pingback: nike free feminino
  309. Pingback: nike air max preto
  310. Pingback: vans brasil
  311. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  312. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  313. Pingback: tenis vans
  314. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  315. Pingback: vans todo preto
  316. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  317. Pingback: tênis vans
  318. Pingback: air max vermelho
  319. Pingback: vans masculino
  320. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  321. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  322. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  323. Pingback: vans todo preto
  324. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  325. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  326. Pingback: loja vans
  327. Pingback: vans era
  328. Pingback: air max feminino
  329. Pingback: nike free feminino
  330. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  331. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  332. Pingback: comprar vans
  333. Pingback: tênis vans
  334. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  335. Pingback: vans rosa
  336. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  337. Pingback: nike max air
  338. Pingback: vans half cab
  339. Pingback: vans era
  340. Pingback: novo air max
  341. Pingback: vans brasil
  342. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  343. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  344. Pingback: loja diesel
  345. Pingback: vans promoção
  346. Pingback: vans feminino
  347. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  348. Pingback: vans brasil
  349. Pingback: lojas armani
  350. Pingback: gucci 托特包
  351. Pingback: gucci 長夾
  352. Pingback: lv 名片夾
  353. Pingback: coach 後背包
  354. Pingback: lv 手錶
  355. Pingback: coach 後背包
  356. Pingback: lv 長夾
  357. Pingback: lv 包包
  358. Pingback: lv 皮夾
  359. Pingback: coach outlet
  360. Pingback: coach 代購
  361. Pingback: lv 包包
  362. Pingback: lv 零錢包
  363. Pingback: lv 官網
  364. Pingback: lv 皮夾
  365. Pingback: lv 名片夾
  366. Pingback: gucci 手錶
  367. Pingback: gucci 皮帶
  368. Pingback: gucci 鑰匙包
  369. Pingback: lv 官網
  370. Pingback: lv 零錢包
  371. Pingback: gucci 太陽眼鏡
  372. Pingback: 香奈兒 香水
  373. Pingback: gucci 皮夾
  374. Pingback: gucci 長夾
  375. Pingback: coach 後背包
  376. Pingback: coach 包包型錄
  377. Pingback: coach 後背包
  378. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  379. Pingback: bag
  380. Pingback: air max feminino
  381. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  382. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  383. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  384. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  385. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  386. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  387. Pingback: vans masculino
  388. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  389. Pingback: air max vermelho
  390. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  391. Pingback: vans era
  392. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  393. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  394. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  395. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  396. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  397. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  398. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  399. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  400. Pingback: nike free feminino
  401. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  402. Pingback: vans masculino
  403. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  404. Pingback: mizuno wave
  405. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  406. Pingback: vans old skool
  407. Pingback: vans brasil
  408. Pingback: vans brasil
  409. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  410. Pingback: vans todo preto
  411. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  412. Pingback: vans half cab
  413. Pingback: air max vermelho
  414. Pingback: vans feminino
  415. Pingback: air max feminino
  416. Pingback: vans era
  417. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  418. Pingback: comprar vans
  419. Pingback: tênis nike free
  420. Pingback: tênis vans
  421. Pingback: vans rosa
  422. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  423. Pingback: tênis nike free
  424. Pingback: nike air max preto
  425. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  426. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  427. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  428. Pingback: tênis vans
  429. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  430. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  431. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  432. Pingback: vans masculino
  433. Pingback: air max azul
  434. Pingback: novo air max
  435. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  436. Pingback: vans rosa
  437. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  438. Pingback: vans half cab
  439. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  440. Pingback: comprar vans
  441. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  442. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  443. Pingback: air max vermelho
  444. Pingback: air max vermelho
  445. Pingback: vans masculino
  446. Pingback: air max vermelho
  447. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  448. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  449. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  450. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  451. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  452. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  453. Pingback: tênis air max
  454. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  455. Pingback: vans old skool
  456. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  457. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  458. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  459. Pingback: comprar vans
  460. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  461. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  462. Pingback: vans old skool
  463. Pingback: vans old skool
  464. Pingback: nike max air
  465. Pingback: loja mizuno
  466. Pingback: air max feminino
  467. Pingback: vans promoção
  468. Pingback: loja vans
  469. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  470. Pingback: nike air max preto
  471. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  472. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  473. Pingback: air max azul
  474. Pingback: vans half cab
  475. Pingback: vans todo preto
  476. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  477. Pingback: comprar vans
  478. Pingback: air max azul
  479. Pingback: nike free feminino
  480. Pingback: nike air max preto
  481. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  482. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  483. Pingback: nike free feminino
  484. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  485. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  486. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  487. Pingback: vans old skool
  488. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  489. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  490. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  491. Pingback: tenis vans
  492. Pingback: loja vans
  493. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  494. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  495. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  496. Pingback: tênis air max
  497. Pingback: tênis vans
  498. Pingback: vans todo preto
  499. Pingback: air max azul
  500. Pingback: mizuno wave
  501. Pingback: nike air max preto
  502. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  503. Pingback: vans todo preto
  504. Pingback: comprar vans
  505. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  506. Pingback: nike air max preto
  507. Pingback: tênis air max
  508. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  509. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  510. Pingback: vans half cab
  511. Pingback: vans era
  512. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  513. Pingback: vans old skool
  514. Pingback: tênis air max
  515. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  516. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  517. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  518. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  519. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  520. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  521. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  522. Pingback: Ralph
  523. Pingback: vans half cab
  524. Pingback: bmi calculator
  525. Pingback: Blue Coaster33
  526. Pingback: water ionizers
  527. Pingback: water ionizer
  528. Pingback: DIRECTV
  529. Pingback: parking
  530. Pingback: lan penge
  531. Pingback: mp4 mobile porn
  532. Pingback: penge laan nu
  533. Pingback: water ionizers
  534. Pingback: car parking
  535. Pingback: water ionizer
  536. Pingback: locksmiths nyc
  537. Pingback: plumbing snake
  538. Pingback: house blue
  539. Pingback: HD Coloring Pages
  540. Pingback: view more
  541. Pingback: alkaline water
  542. Pingback: car insurance
  543. Pingback: alkaline water
  544. Pingback: water ionizer
  545. Pingback: link
  546. Pingback: here