An Empty Core

Field testing for the multi-state assessments for the Common Core State Standards began last week. Chris Minnich, the executive director of the Council of Chief State School Officers, which oversaw the drafting of the CCSS with the National Governor’s Association, heralded the events in  the Huffington Post:

The promise of Common Core standards, now being implemented in more than 40 states, is that they set a higher bar for what students should know and understand at each grade level. What hasn’t changed is that even under these new standards, individual teachers and schools will continue to decide how best to teach their students to meet them. But because the Common Core standards are more rigorous expectations, carefully researched and pegged to meet or exceed what students in other high-performing countries are learning, they will discourage learning-by-memorizing drills and “teaching to the test.”

The aim is noble, but good intentions do not make good policy. Minnich says that the standards are more rigorous and “require students to develop and demonstrate stronger mastery of core subject matter.” The CCSS do not set out a curriculum for meeting them, though many publishers are offering such curricula ostensibly based on the standards. For those of us who have read them, it is by no means clear that a “higher bar” is set or that they enable “stronger mastery of core subject matter.” Instead, they often ask students to explain how they multiplied after multiplying 5 x 4, to which my daughter answers “by multiplying, duh!” Or asking for “evidence” from a story to explain why one character felt they way he or she did, and by evidence they mean quoting back a line from the text.

But let’s stipulate that the standards do require stronger mastery and higher learning. How then will schools and teachers revise their curricula to meet these new standards? Developing state-wide assessments should be the last step in rolling out the CCSS but instead it is the first step. Since the standards seek a progression from kindergarten—yes, now a half-day kindergarten must meet the same standards as a full-day kindergarten—how are teachers supposed to bring a 6th, 7th, or 8th grader up these higher standards when they were taught under lesser standards in their K-5 years? Either the standards are not substantively different and so this will take only a little extra time and effort,  or the standards are in fact significantly more rigorous and improving student instruction will take much more time and effort. If the latter, then the assessments come too soon. We know that many children do not meet the bar for old standards.

For once, an athletic analogy is appropriate for educational achievement. If an athlete cannot leap over a low hurdle, you do not improve his or her performance by raising the height of the hurdle.

930 thoughts on “An Empty Core

  1. Pingback: more information
  2. Pingback: Buy it cheap here
  3. Pingback: max
  4. Pingback: url opener
  5. Pingback: Randy
  6. Pingback: jon
  7. Pingback: Jorge
  8. Pingback: wayne
  9. Pingback: herman
  10. Pingback: lester
  11. Pingback: Louis
  12. Pingback: Eugene
  13. Pingback: Konzert
  14. Pingback: ralph
  15. Pingback: jonathan
  16. Pingback: Dave
  17. Pingback: alfonso
  18. Pingback: hampton bay
  19. Pingback: mark
  20. Pingback: Wayne
  21. Pingback: hampton bay
  22. Pingback: howard
  23. Pingback: hampton bay fans
  24. Pingback: mr bean
  25. Pingback: julian
  26. Pingback: Matthew
  27. Pingback: Travis
  28. Pingback: warren
  29. Pingback: ken
  30. Pingback: Jimmie
  31. Pingback: Ernest
  32. Pingback: Brandon
  33. Pingback: clenbuterol price
  34. Pingback: Marion
  35. Pingback: tyrone
  36. Pingback: Keith
  37. Pingback: nelson
  38. Pingback: Lance
  39. Pingback: hugh
  40. Pingback: Ben
  41. Pingback: air max pas cher
  42. Pingback: tn requin pas cher
  43. Pingback: mulberry outlet uk
  44. Pingback: nike air max homme
  45. Pingback: bjbKpIbB
  46. Pingback: Alexander
  47. Pingback: Chester
  48. Pingback: francis
  49. Pingback: Garcinia Cambogia
  50. Pingback: rolex brasil
  51. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  52. Pingback: relógios rolex
  53. Pingback: rolex feminino
  54. Pingback: rolex preço
  55. Pingback: rolex brasil
  56. Pingback: relógio rolex
  57. Pingback: loja armani
  58. Pingback: relógio armani
  59. Pingback: relógio armani
  60. Pingback: relógio armani
  61. Pingback: relógios rolex
  62. Pingback: comprar rolex
  63. Pingback: rolex preço
  64. Pingback: relógios rolex
  65. Pingback: rolex preço
  66. Pingback: relogios da armani
  67. Pingback: relogios da armani
  68. Pingback: relógio armani
  69. Pingback: lojas armani
  70. Pingback: rolex feminino
  71. Pingback: rolex brasil
  72. Pingback: rolex original
  73. Pingback: loja armani
  74. Pingback: rolex original
  75. Pingback: relógio armani
  76. Pingback: lojas armani
  77. Pingback: doutor rolex
  78. Pingback: rolex brasil
  79. Pingback: rolex original
  80. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  81. Pingback: lojas armani
  82. Pingback: lojas armani
  83. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  84. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  85. Pingback: armani ar5860
  86. Pingback: rolex original
  87. Pingback: comprar rolex
  88. Pingback: rolex preço
  89. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  90. Pingback: loja diesel
  91. Pingback: lojas armani
  92. Pingback: rolex brasil
  93. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  94. Pingback: relógio rolex
  95. Pingback: relógios diesel
  96. Pingback: rolex brasil
  97. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  98. Pingback: rolex original
  99. Pingback: relogios da armani
  100. Pingback: relogios da armani
  101. Pingback: relógio armani
  102. Pingback: rolex feminino
  103. Pingback: rolex original
  104. Pingback: relogios da armani
  105. Pingback: rolex brasil
  106. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  107. Pingback: loja armani
  108. Pingback: rolex feminino
  109. Pingback: diesel brasil
  110. Pingback: relógio diesel
  111. Pingback: diesel brasil
  112. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  113. Pingback: rolex original
  114. Pingback: relógios rolex
  115. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  116. Pingback: relógio rolex
  117. Pingback: loja diesel
  118. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  119. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  120. Pingback: relogio diesel dz
  121. Pingback: rolex brasil
  122. Pingback: diesel brasil
  123. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  124. Pingback: relogios da armani
  125. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  126. Pingback: relógios rolex
  127. Pingback: relogios da armani
  128. Pingback: loja armani
  129. Pingback: relogios da armani
  130. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  131. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  132. Pingback: relógio armani
  133. Pingback: armani ar5860
  134. Pingback: lojas armani
  135. Pingback: relogios da armani
  136. Pingback: rolex original
  137. Pingback: rolex original
  138. Pingback: brett
  139. Pingback: rolex brasil
  140. Pingback: rolex feminino
  141. Pingback: rolex preço
  142. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  143. Pingback: armani ar5860
  144. Pingback: relógios diesel
  145. Pingback: comprar rolex
  146. Pingback: armani ar5860
  147. Pingback: rolex original
  148. Pingback: rolex preço
  149. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  150. Pingback: rolex feminino
  151. Pingback: loja diesel
  152. Pingback: comprar rolex
  153. Pingback: comprar rolex
  154. Pingback: rolex original
  155. Pingback: doutor rolex
  156. Pingback: diesel brasil
  157. Pingback: relógio da diesel
  158. Pingback: relógios diesel
  159. Pingback: loja diesel
  160. Pingback: relogios da armani
  161. Pingback: armani ar5860
  162. Pingback: rolex feminino
  163. Pingback: rolex preço
  164. Pingback: rolex mais barato
  165. Pingback: rolex de ouro
  166. Pingback: comprar rolex
  167. Pingback: comprar rolex
  168. Pingback: relógios famosos
  169. Pingback: relógios rolex
  170. Pingback: diesel brasil
  171. Pingback: loja diesel
  172. Pingback: 香奈兒 官網
  173. Pingback: chanel 耳環
  174. Pingback: lv 包包最新款
  175. Pingback: lv 發財包
  176. Pingback: coach 長夾
  177. Pingback: coach 手拿包
  178. Pingback: coach 手拿包
  179. Pingback: lv 手錶
  180. Pingback: lv neverfull
  181. Pingback: lv 旗艦店
  182. Pingback: armani ar5860
  183. Pingback: mizuno wave
  184. Pingback: nike air max preto
  185. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  186. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  187. Pingback: vans promoção
  188. Pingback: gucci 太陽眼鏡
  189. Pingback: gucci 長夾
  190. Pingback: gucci 鑰匙包
  191. Pingback: chanel 耳環
  192. Pingback: 香奈兒 包包
  193. Pingback: chanel 皮夾
  194. Pingback: 香奈兒 皮夾
  195. Pingback: gucci 皮帶
  196. Pingback: 香奈兒 手錶
  197. Pingback: gucci 台灣
  198. Pingback: gucci 台灣
  199. Pingback: chanel j12
  200. Pingback: chanel coco包
  201. Pingback: chanel 手錶
  202. Pingback: gucci 皮夾
  203. Pingback: chanel coco包
  204. Pingback: gucci 長夾
  205. Pingback: gucci 手錶
  206. Pingback: relógios famosos
  207. Pingback: relógios famosos
  208. Pingback: nike free feminino
  209. Pingback: air max feminino
  210. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  211. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  212. Pingback: a&f 外套
  213. Pingback: a&f 台灣專櫃
  214. Pingback: a&f ella 外套
  215. Pingback: a&f 台灣
  216. Pingback: a&f outlet
  217. Pingback: a&f 官網
  218. Pingback: a&f 尺寸
  219. Pingback: a&f 香水
  220. Pingback: a&f 香水
  221. Pingback: a&f 香水
  222. Pingback: a&f 官網
  223. Pingback: a&f 官網
  224. Pingback: a&f 尺寸
  225. Pingback: a&f 台灣專櫃
  226. Pingback: a&f 外套
  227. Pingback: vans half cab
  228. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  229. Pingback: tênis vans
  230. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  231. Pingback: tenis vans
  232. Pingback: vans brasil
  233. Pingback: nike max air
  234. Pingback: tênis nike free
  235. Pingback: vans masculino
  236. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  237. Pingback: air max azul
  238. Pingback: air max vermelho
  239. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  240. Pingback: nike air max preto
  241. Pingback: nike air max preto
  242. Pingback: vans old skool
  243. Pingback: vans half cab
  244. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  245. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  246. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  247. Pingback: air max vermelho
  248. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  249. Pingback: comprar vans
  250. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  251. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  252. Pingback: vans old skool
  253. Pingback: air max feminino
  254. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  255. Pingback: air max azul
  256. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  257. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  258. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  259. Pingback: vans todo preto
  260. Pingback: novo mizuno
  261. Pingback: vans half cab
  262. Pingback: novo mizuno
  263. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  264. Pingback: nike air max preto
  265. Pingback: vans feminino
  266. Pingback: loja vans
  267. Pingback: air max vermelho
  268. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  269. Pingback: vans era
  270. Pingback: vans brasil
  271. Pingback: vans brasil
  272. Pingback: nike max air
  273. Pingback: vans promoção
  274. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  275. Pingback: 香奈兒 香水
  276. Pingback: 香奈兒 手錶
  277. Pingback: chanel 2.55
  278. Pingback: 香奈兒 皮夾
  279. Pingback: gucci 皮帶
  280. Pingback: gucci 鑰匙包
  281. Pingback: gucci 零錢包
  282. Pingback: nike free feminino
  283. Pingback: vans old skool
  284. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  285. Pingback: air max azul
  286. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  287. Pingback: vans masculino
  288. Pingback: tênis nike free
  289. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  290. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  291. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  292. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  293. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  294. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  295. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  296. Pingback: coach 皮夾
  297. Pingback: coach 皮夾
  298. Pingback: coach 長夾
  299. Pingback: coach 包包
  300. Pingback: coach 斜背包
  301. Pingback: coach 代購
  302. Pingback: coach 零錢包
  303. Pingback: coach 包包型錄
  304. Pingback: coach outlet
  305. Pingback: coach 包包
  306. Pingback: coach 代購
  307. Pingback: vans promoção
  308. Pingback: vans half cab
  309. Pingback: tenis vans
  310. Pingback: vans half cab
  311. Pingback: vans era
  312. Pingback: air max vermelho
  313. Pingback: loja vans
  314. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  315. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  316. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  317. Pingback: vans brasil
  318. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  319. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  320. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  321. Pingback: vans brasil
  322. Pingback: vans era
  323. Pingback: novo mizuno
  324. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  325. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  326. Pingback: tênis air max
  327. Pingback: nike air max preto
  328. Pingback: loja mizuno
  329. Pingback: vans todo preto
  330. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  331. Pingback: novo mizuno
  332. Pingback: nike max air
  333. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  334. Pingback: tênis nike free
  335. Pingback: vans old skool
  336. Pingback: novo air max
  337. Pingback: nike free feminino
  338. Pingback: novo mizuno
  339. Pingback: novo mizuno
  340. Pingback: vans half cab
  341. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  342. Pingback: tenis vans
  343. Pingback: vans brasil
  344. Pingback: vans todo preto
  345. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  346. Pingback: vans feminino
  347. Pingback: vans masculino
  348. Pingback: loja mizuno
  349. Pingback: vans todo preto
  350. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  351. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  352. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  353. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  354. Pingback: air max vermelho
  355. Pingback: tenis vans
  356. Pingback: nike free feminino
  357. Pingback: novo air max
  358. Pingback: tênis air max
  359. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  360. Pingback: vans todo preto
  361. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  362. Pingback: nike air max preto
  363. Pingback: vans old skool
  364. Pingback: tênis air max
  365. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  366. Pingback: vans todo preto
  367. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  368. Pingback: air max vermelho
  369. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  370. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  371. Pingback: mizuno wave
  372. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  373. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  374. Pingback: tênis air max
  375. Pingback: vans todo preto
  376. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  377. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  378. Pingback: vans masculino
  379. Pingback: tenis vans
  380. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  381. Pingback: vans feminino
  382. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  383. Pingback: vans rosa
  384. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  385. Pingback: tênis air max
  386. Pingback: loja mizuno
  387. Pingback: mizuno prophecy 2
  388. Pingback: vans era
  389. Pingback: comprar vans
  390. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  391. Pingback: air max feminino
  392. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  393. Pingback: tênis nike free
  394. Pingback: loja mizuno
  395. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  396. Pingback: comprar vans
  397. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  398. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  399. Pingback: vans promoção
  400. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  401. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  402. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  403. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  404. Pingback: vans brasil
  405. Pingback: tênis air max
  406. Pingback: air max feminino
  407. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  408. Pingback: nike air max preto
  409. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  410. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  411. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  412. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  413. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  414. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  415. Pingback: vans era
  416. Pingback: loja mizuno
  417. Pingback: nike air max preto
  418. Pingback: vans feminino
  419. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  420. Pingback: loja mizuno
  421. Pingback: air max vermelho
  422. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  423. Pingback: vans feminino
  424. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  425. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  426. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  427. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  428. Pingback: vans masculino
  429. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  430. Pingback: mizuno prorunner
  431. Pingback: nike air max preto
  432. Pingback: nike air max preto
  433. Pingback: vans old skool
  434. Pingback: vans promoção
  435. Pingback: tênis nike free
  436. Pingback: air max feminino
  437. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  438. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  439. Pingback: vans era
  440. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  441. Pingback: nike air max 2012
  442. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  443. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  444. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  445. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  446. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  447. Pingback: loja mizuno
  448. Pingback: vans promoção
  449. Pingback: tênis vans preto
  450. Pingback: comprar vans
  451. Pingback: nike free feminino
  452. Pingback: loja vans
  453. Pingback: novo air max
  454. Pingback: loja vans
  455. Pingback: novo mizuno
  456. Pingback: air max vermelho
  457. Pingback: vans todo preto
  458. Pingback: vans half cab
  459. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  460. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  461. Pingback: loja vans
  462. Pingback: vans half cab
  463. Pingback: air max azul
  464. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  465. Pingback: vans feminino
  466. Pingback: novo air max 2014
  467. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  468. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  469. Pingback: loja vans
  470. Pingback: tênis vans
  471. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  472. Pingback: tênis air max
  473. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  474. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  475. Pingback: tênis vans
  476. Pingback: vans feminino
  477. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  478. Pingback: vans rosa
  479. Pingback: air max feminino
  480. Pingback: mizuno wave
  481. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  482. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  483. Pingback: novo air max
  484. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  485. Pingback: nike free flyknit
  486. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  487. Pingback: tênis air max
  488. Pingback: vans brasil
  489. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  490. Pingback: vans era
  491. Pingback: vans era
  492. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  493. Pingback: air max vermelho
  494. Pingback: novo air max
  495. Pingback: vans feminino
  496. Pingback: nike free feminino
  497. Pingback: nike air max preto
  498. Pingback: vans todo preto
  499. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  500. Pingback: vans brasil
  501. Pingback: vans masculino
  502. Pingback: tênis vans barato
  503. Pingback: air max vermelho
  504. Pingback: vans old skool
  505. Pingback: vans rosa
  506. Pingback: mizuno brasil
  507. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  508. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  509. Pingback: tênis vans
  510. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  511. Pingback: vans promoção
  512. Pingback: nike max air
  513. Pingback: vans brasil
  514. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  515. Pingback: tênis vans verde
  516. Pingback: vans old skool
  517. Pingback: tenis vans
  518. Pingback: air max azul
  519. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  520. Pingback: loja vans
  521. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  522. Pingback: tenis mizuno wave
  523. Pingback: air max feminino
  524. Pingback: vans rosa
  525. Pingback: vans half cab
  526. Pingback: tênis vans
  527. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  528. Pingback: chuteira mizuno
  529. Pingback: air max azul
  530. Pingback: tenis vans
  531. Pingback: nike free 3.0
  532. Pingback: vans brasil
  533. Pingback: tênis vans
  534. Pingback: vans brasil
  535. Pingback: mizuno feminino
  536. Pingback: novo mizuno
  537. Pingback: vans todo preto
  538. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  539. Pingback: mizuno wave 2
  540. Pingback: tênis mizuno
  541. Pingback: tenis air max 90
  542. Pingback: nike air max 2013
  543. Pingback: vans todo preto
  544. Pingback: tênis nike free
  545. Pingback: vans promoção
  546. Pingback: vans brasil
  547. Pingback: chanel
  548. Pingback: Vanessa Smith
  549. Pingback: download firefox
  550. Pingback: javascript
  551. Pingback: air max.com
  552. Pingback: nike free 5.0 uk
  553. Pingback: net
  554. Pingback: click here